Yankees Face Criticism for Benching Jazz Chisholm in AL Wild Card Loss

The New York Yankees faced criticism after manager Aaron Boone benched star second baseman Jazz Chisholm Jr. in Game 1 of the AL Wild Card Round against the Boston Red Sox, a decision that did not pay off as the Yankees lost 3-1. Chisholm, who had a 30-30 season and was a key offensive player, was replaced by Amed Rosario, who went hitless in three plate appearances against lefty Garrett Crochet. Former Yankees players and fans expressed frustration, arguing that Chisholm deserved to start, especially given his overall performance against left-handed pitchers, and criticized Boone for relying too heavily on analytics. Chisholm himself showed visible displeasure, conducting his postgame interview with his back to reporters and revealing that he was informed of the benching via text with limited discussion. Boone defended the decision by citing Rosario's better history against Crochet and defensive considerations, but the move has sparked debate about whether the Yankees undermined their chances by not playing their best player. The Yankees will likely turn back to Chisholm in the must-win Game 2, hoping he can overcome the benching and help the team advance.