Court Backs Miss Lizzie's Coffee in Trademark Case

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit has upheld the right of Miss Lizzie’s Coffee to continue operating next to the Lizzie Borden House despite a trademark infringement lawsuit filed by U.S. Ghost Adventures, which runs the bed and breakfast and museum at the site of the Borden family murders. The court found that the ghost tour company failed to demonstrate a likelihood of confusion between the two businesses, which is critical for trademark claims. Although Ghost Adventures holds a trademark on the name 'Lizzie Borden' and a specific hatchet logo, the court noted that Miss Lizzie’s signage is distinct and does not infringe on those rights. The coffee shop has clarified its independent status with signage indicating no affiliation with the bed and breakfast. This legal battle highlights the enduring fascination with the infamous Borden case and its impact on local businesses. The appeals court’s decision allows the coffee shop to keep serving patrons while the lawsuit continues.