Supreme Court Lowers Standard in Disability School Cases

The U.S. Supreme Court unanimously ruled in favor of Ava Tharpe, a Minnesota student with severe epilepsy, significantly strengthening protections for students with disabilities in schools nationwide. The Court decided that families suing under the Americans with Disabilities Act and the Rehabilitation Act no longer need to prove 'bad faith or gross misjudgment' by school officials, but instead must show 'deliberate indifference.' This ruling harmonizes legal standards across the country, making it easier for families to file disability discrimination claims and seek damages when reasonable accommodations are denied. Advocates have welcomed the decision as a major victory for disability rights and equal access to education. The Osseo Area Schools district, the defendant, acknowledged the decision and its implications. The ruling is expected to increase school districts' accountability in providing appropriate accommodations.