The Old Guard 2 Debuts on Netflix Amid Widespread Critical Backlash

The Old Guard 2, the sequel to the 2020 Netflix hit starring Charlize Theron, debuted to mixed and largely negative critical reception despite quickly reaching the top spot on Netflix's U.S. charts. Directed by Victoria Mahoney, the film continues the story of immortal warriors, introducing new characters and conflicts, but critics have widely criticized its convoluted plot, poor pacing, and technical issues such as fight choreography and sound quality. While reviewers appreciated Theron's performance and the slick action sequences, many found the narrative rushed and emotionally shallow compared to the original, with some calling it a potential franchise-killer. Critics from outlets including The Guardian, The Times (UK), and The Daily Beast described it as poorly developed and confusing, though some acknowledged its entertainment value for fans of the franchise. The film currently holds a low rating on Rotten Tomatoes (around 25-28%), a sharp decline from the first film's 80% approval. Despite these criticisms, the sequel's release amid challenges like the pandemic and industry strikes marks an important continuation of the franchise.