Yankees Evaluate Ben Rice, Austin Wells for Starting Catcher Role

Ben Rice has emerged as a strong contender for the New York Yankees' starting catcher role, delivering both offensive and defensive value that the team currently needs amid a playoff push. Rice's performance, including a .281 batting average and praised defensive skills such as pitch framing and game management, contrasts sharply with Austin Wells' recent slump, as Wells has struggled with a .213 average since July and difficulties recognizing breaking balls. Manager Aaron Boone has acknowledged Rice's progress and praised his handling of pitchers but has maintained a cautious approach, opting not to definitively name Rice the starter, instead keeping lineup flexibility during this critical part of the season. The Yankees face roster challenges involving key players like Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton, which complicates decisions about Rice's role, as he has also played first base and could serve as a designated hitter, especially with Judge's ongoing injury concerns. With the Yankees scoring among the lowest in runs recently, Rice's offensive spark and defensive reliability could be pivotal, potentially foreshadowing a shift in the catcher position for the remainder of 2025 and beyond. Boone's strategy reflects a balance between rewarding Rice's hot streak and managing team dynamics, while Wells continues efforts to adjust and reclaim his role.