Vikings Weigh McCarthy’s Preseason Debut, Training Concerns

Minnesota Vikings quarterback J.J. McCarthy, who missed his rookie season due to a knee injury, has returned as the team's starting quarterback for 2025 and played his first preseason game, showing promise with a strong opening drive before being quickly pulled. McCarthy's approachable personality and viral fan interactions have made him popular among supporters, and teammates like Justin Jefferson are focused on building his confidence. While some observers highlight his leadership and willingness to learn, insiders such as The Athletic’s Dianna Russini report that he has not been impressive in training camp, warning that Vikings fans may face disappointment. McCarthy's commitment is underscored by his defense of a teammate during a heated practice moment, a trait linked to his hockey background. The Vikings’ season depends heavily on McCarthy’s development, and while there is optimism, concerns remain regarding his readiness for the starting role.