Sentencing Council Rejects Justice Secretary's Guidance Changes in 'Two-Tier' Justice Debate

The Sentencing Council has rejected Justice Secretary Shabana Mahmood's request to amend new guidelines that suggest judges consider a defendant's ethnicity when determining sentencing. The guidelines, set to take effect in April, require pre-sentence reports for individuals from ethnic, cultural, or faith minorities, as well as other vulnerable groups. Mahmood expressed her disappointment, arguing that the guidelines create a 'two-tier' justice system where outcomes may be influenced by race or culture. Despite her objections, the council maintained that the guidelines do not require revision but will clarify the language to address misunderstandings. Tory shadow justice secretary Robert Jenrick criticized the guidelines, asserting they could undermine public trust in the justice system. Mahmood has indicated that she may pursue legislative changes if necessary.