Nathan Cleary and the Penrith Panthers have solidified their status in rugby league history by winning their fourth consecutive premiership title after defeating Melbourne Storm 14-6. This achievement has ignited debates about the Panthers' standing among the greatest teams, particularly in comparison to the legendary Parramatta Eels of the 1980s. Former Eels player Ray Price dismissed the notion that the Panthers surpass his team, asserting that the Eels were a stronger side. Cleary responded indirectly on social media, signaling his disagreement, while co-captain Isaah Yeo also rejected the claims. Despite their success, Cleary announced he will undergo shoulder surgery, which will sideline him from the upcoming Pacific Championships, although it may allow him to reunite with his partner earlier than expected. The Panthers' future remains uncertain with key player departures looming as they aim for a fifth title.