Blue Jays Lead Yankees 2-0 in ALDS Amid Pitch-Tipping Allegations

The 2025 ALDS between the New York Yankees and Toronto Blue Jays has been marked by intense rivalry and strategic mind games, with allegations surfacing that Blue Jays pitcher Seranthony Domínguez may be tipping his pitches, a concern being investigated by Blue Jays manager John Schneider. Yankees players, notably Aaron Judge, have been observed using psychological tactics, such as helmet tapping to signal pitches, which has been acknowledged as a strategic method to unsettle opposing pitchers. The Blue Jays have dominated the series early, including a significant 13-7 victory in Game 2, where rookie Trey Yesavage's splitter proved devastating against the Yankees. Manager Aaron Boone has faced scrutiny for lineup decisions, particularly choosing to start Ben Rice over veteran Paul Goldschmidt at first base, reflecting a shift toward trusting younger power hitters. Despite past criticisms from Blue Jays broadcaster Buck Martinez dismissing the Yankees' abilities, the rivalry has intensified with both teams performing strongly throughout the season and postseason. The Yankees' resilience is being tested as they attempt to respond to the Blue Jays' momentum in the series.