Josh Allen Ranked Fourth Despite MVP Season

Despite Buffalo Bills quarterback Josh Allen's 2024 NFL MVP season and leading all quarterbacks with a 95.4 PFF grade over the past three years, several analysts, including PFF's John Kosko, have ranked him fourth behind Patrick Mahomes, Joe Burrow, and Lamar Jackson in both NFL and fantasy football lists. Allen is the only quarterback to have scored 40 or more total touchdowns in five consecutive seasons. Critics contend that Allen's ability to consistently elevate his team and produce despite roster changes should merit a higher ranking. Some projections, such as those by ESPN's Mike Clay, predict a significant statistical decline for Allen in 2025, a viewpoint many dispute due to his consistent performance and strengthened supporting cast. In fantasy football, Allen's ranking below Lamar Jackson remains controversial given his MVP status and history as a top-three scorer. The ongoing debate underscores a perceived disconnect between Allen's achievements and his recognition among NFL elite quarterbacks.