David Warner's recent comments about potentially making a Test comeback for Australia have garnered mixed reactions, particularly from former Australian cricketers Chris Rogers, Moises Henriques, and Lisa Sthalekar. Warner, who announced his retirement earlier this year after a farewell match, expressed his readiness to play in the upcoming Border-Gavaskar Trophy if needed, citing his preparation and the team's lack of suitable opening options. Critics argue that his return would not only overshadow the farewell he received but also signal a regression for the Test team, as his recent performances against India have been subpar. Additionally, many believe that the selectors should not consider him, as it reflects poorly on the current batting lineup. In contrast, some defend Warner, asserting that he deserves respect for his significant contributions to Australian cricket over the years. Overall, the debate underscores the challenges facing Australia's batting order ahead of a crucial Test series against India.