Carrie Underwood Shares Emotional Moments as American Idol Judge

Carrie Underwood, returning to American Idol as a judge two decades after her own win, has found the role emotionally challenging, particularly when it comes to sending contestants home—a responsibility she admits she dislikes and wishes could be left to the viewers. Fellow judge Lionel Richie initially worried that Underwood's well-known kindness would make it difficult for her to navigate the sometimes tough demands of judging, but he has since praised the compassion and fresh perspective she brings to the panel. Underwood's empathy was especially evident during a recent faith-based episode, where she was moved to tears by a heartfelt performance from The Brown Four, a young gospel group, in a moment unseen by cameras. Despite the emotional toll, Underwood expresses that she enjoys the experience and values the opportunity to support aspiring singers, while also acknowledging the weight of influencing their futures. Her approach has been described as both nurturing and impactful, reshaping the dynamic among the judges. Underwood's return has been well-received, blending her fan perspective with her personal journey on the show.