Dave Portnoy Criticizes Zach Bryan Over Ex-Girlfriend Lookalike Allegations

Barstool Sports founder Dave Portnoy has strongly criticized country singer Zach Bryan for reportedly dating Samantha Leonard, a woman who closely resembles Bryan's ex-girlfriend and Barstool colleague Brianna “Chickenfry” LaPaglia. Portnoy called Bryan a “psychopath” for allegedly seeking a “Brianna 2.0” and expressed disbelief over the striking similarities between Leonard and LaPaglia, which have sparked widespread online discussion. The feud between Bryan and LaPaglia has been highly public and contentious, with LaPaglia accusing Bryan of emotional abuse and refusing a $12 million NDA offer, while Bryan has denied some allegations and reignited tensions through his music and social media actions. Bryan also drew criticism for a social media video in which he burned a Barstool Sports flag, seen as a direct shot at LaPaglia. Both parties have continued to publicly exchange accusations, with LaPaglia sharing evidence and Bryan disputing claims, keeping their breakup drama in the spotlight. Portnoy has been vocal in defending LaPaglia throughout the ongoing dispute, repeatedly attacking Bryan in podcasts and social media.