Court Strikes Down New York Ivory Sale Ban

The 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has ruled unconstitutional a New York law that banned the sale and display of ivory and rhinoceros horns by antiques dealers, asserting a violation of First Amendment rights regarding commercial speech. The court found the law excessively broad, restricting communication about the authenticity and quality of legally salable ivory goods, and imposed stricter conditions than federal regulations under the Endangered Species Act. Despite the law's conservation intentions, aimed at protecting declining elephant and rhinoceros populations, the court sided with trade groups who argued it hindered lawful marketing. Dissenting Judge Richard Sullivan emphasized the law's conflict with federal regulations, while animal rights groups expressed concern that the decision could undermine conservation efforts. New York's Department of Environmental Conservation is currently reviewing the ruling, which could have significant implications for the state's wildlife protection policies.