NFL Teams Face Questionable Quarterback Rooms for 2025 Season

As the 2025 football season approaches, quarterback rooms across college and the NFL display a wide range of talent and readiness. LSU leads the college ranks with a strong quarterback room featuring Heisman candidate Garrett Nussmeier and promising backups, while Clemson and Oklahoma also boast top-tier quarterback talent, including high-performing starters like Cade Klubnik and John Mateer. Conversely, the Minnesota Vikings have committed fully to young quarterback J.J. McCarthy as their starter despite having multiple quarterbacks in the room, signaling a clear but somewhat paradoxical plan. In the NFL, some teams face uncertainty and criticism over their quarterback depth, notably the New Orleans Saints, whose quarterback room is deemed "laughable" following Derek Carr's sudden medical retirement, leaving them reliant on less proven players like Tyler Shough and Jake Haener. Other NFL teams such as the New York Jets and Indianapolis Colts are in transitional phases, with questionable depth and plans that may hinge on future drafts. Overall, quarterback rooms remain a critical focus as teams strive to balance experienced starters with capable backups to ensure competitive success in the upcoming season.