San Francisco 49ers Receive D Grade for 2025 Offseason Amid Key Player Departures

The San Francisco 49ers had a tumultuous offseason marked by significant contract extensions for key players Brock Purdy, George Kittle, and Fred Warner, but also by the departure of several veteran contributors such as Deebo Samuel Sr., Charvarius Ward, and Dre Greenlaw. While the front office focused on retaining star talent and made coaching staff improvements, their free agency period was considered lackluster with limited impactful additions, leading Pro Football Network to assign a disappointing 'D' grade to their overall offseason performance. The 49ers' 2025 draft class received mixed reviews, with some promising prospects like Mykel Williams, C.J. West, and Alfred Collins but lingering questions about their ability to significantly bolster a defense that struggled in run defense metrics. Despite the defensive overhaul and optimism around the coaching, external playoff predictions have been pessimistic, omitting the 49ers from postseason forecasts and suggesting another disappointing season. Critics note that while the grade reflects valid concerns, the limited quality of available free agents could explain the team's cautious approach. Ultimately, the Niners face a challenging season ahead with high hopes but a roster that may not yet be ready to contend at the highest level.