NFL Analysts Rank Quarterbacks with Most to Prove 2025 Season

As the 2025 NFL season approaches, quarterback evaluations and expectations are a major focus. Pat Surtain II of the Denver Broncos included not only established stars like Patrick Mahomes and Lamar Jackson but also his teammate Bo Nix, predicting a breakout year for Nix due to his increased composure and leadership. ESPN analyst Dan Orlovsky identified five quarterbacks with the most to prove this season: Anthony Richardson, Bryce Young, J.J. McCarthy, Trevor Lawrence, and Caleb Williams, with Williams viewed as a potential future star but still needing to validate his status after a mixed rookie year. Orlovsky's ranking sparked debate, particularly regarding Caleb Williams and Trevor Lawrence, as some disagree with Williams being seen as having more to prove despite his rookie season challenges. Additionally, quarterback longevity varies widely, with many serving as journeymen across multiple teams, highlighting the difficulty of maintaining a stable NFL career at the position. Overall, the spotlight remains on these quarterbacks to either solidify their reputations or overcome skepticism in the impending season.